Hey Anonymous! Register

•  Forum home  »  General  »  Cropping to 1920x1080 or 1920x1200?
Cropping to 1920x1080 or 1920x1200?


  10 total replies (1 pages)
10 total replies (1 pages)
Bukssna
advanced writer
  Written 10 months  1 day ago       Last edited by   Thirteen 10 months  1 day ago
I was wondering.. What is the most popular resolution on this site? Is there some kind of statistic to back it up?

But what I actually mean to ask is when uploading walls, what is the resolution I should choose when resizing? Because I usually do that and since my screen is 1680x1050, I naturally choose 1920x1200... But do users prefer HD (1920x1080)? Or any other size?

Thirteen
dominator
  Written 10 months  1 day ago      
There's nothing wrong with leaving wallpapers in the original resolution you find them in, as most users use the "or greater" resolution search option, so the highest resolution you can find without a loss of quality (i.e. without upscaling the wallpaper yourself) would usually be preferable.

As to what is the most popular resolution, I have no idea but I use a pair of 1920x1080 screens if that helps. NYAN CAT!

Bukssna
advanced writer
  Written 10 months  1 day ago       Last edited by   Bukssna 10 months  1 day ago
^Yeah well when I find large vertical pics and want to make them horizontal I always have a dilemma whether to make it 1920x1200 or 1920x1080, so that's in fact the main purpose of this topic... Maybe you should rename it to - 1920x1200 or 1920x1080 lol

Epic Man ... Philip
like a boss!
  Written 10 months  1 day ago      
Although the 1920x1080 is the hd res. that i preffer the minimum required for a wallpaper to be featured is 1920x1200, so i try to upload 1920x1200 as often as i can...Both are awesome if you ask me...

Yuasu
bends spacetime
  Written 10 months  1 day ago      
1920x1080, because the parts are in hd than 1920x1200

scissorhands
professional spammer
  Written 10 months  21 hours ago      
well, if you're cropping a portrait image to a landscape, then you're basically creating a derivative work of art(assuming that's what the original is), since you are choosing what part of the image gets deleted and what is kept, in effect changing the focus of the piece. and if you're doing that, you might as well create 2 of them and upload both 1200 and 1080, because if you're creating the 1200 to upload, why not create your own version of the 1080 too? people using 1080 are free to download the 1200 and crop their own 1080, but if you feel that the image should be cropped in a certain way...

or you could just leave the portrait as it is while uploading and let others crop as they are wont. that way you're not creating a derivative work, you're only sharing. personally, i think if i were a photographer or some such, i would not mind, sharing of my work as much as the distortion of the vision.

cropping for personal use is different of course... its akin to what you focus on naturally when you see an image..its what pops out to you. it's based on the individual's perception of an artist's work.

Cornelius Funk
dominator
  Written 9 months  3 weeks ago      
1920x1080 is a safe bet, but if the image fits the guidelines then the original res is fine. There's no harm in uploading the largest (original, not upscaled...) copy of an image, since it works for everyone.

LWTBP
professional spammer
  Written 9 months  6 days ago      

  Written 8 months  3 weeks ago       Last edited by   ridethesky 8 months  3 weeks ago
Don't crop. Upload a original image and let me decide how much do I want to crop, if even. There are 24" monitors with 1920x1200 or 1920x1080 native resolution. You _will_ fiill all of 1080p with 1920x1200 wallpaper, that's obvious, but not vice versa. All of all, 1920x1200 is more wise choice.

Einhard
advanced writer
  Written 8 months  3 weeks ago      
ridethesky wrote:
Don't crop. Upload a original image and let me decide how much do I want to crop, if even. There are 24" monitors with 1920x1200 or 1920x1080 native resolution. You _will_ fiill all of 1080p with 1920x1200 wallpaper, that's obvious, but not vice versa. All of all, 1920x1200 is more wise choice.


Absolutely ! Just make them 16:10 ! it doesen't matter if this means 5184 x 3240 or 2560 x 1600 or 1920 x 1200. Use the best quality! and don't post 10:16 or such stuff, sometimes there are nice pictures, but you can't use them as wallpaper.

camillem210
freshman
  Written 1 week  2 days ago      
HI,there
you just need to search for a third part image editor to get this job done.most image editors are capable of this .Im customed to use image cropping component in C#,By the way ,Im a fresh programmer.

•  Forum home  »  General  »  Cropping to 1920x1080 or 1920x1200?