Hey Anonymous! Register

•  Forum home  »  Tagging  »  Better tag suggestions when tagging
Better tag suggestions when tagging


  12 total replies (1 pages)
12 total replies (1 pages)
Eclapa
professional spammer
  Written 10 months  1 week ago       Last edited by   chibi 10 months  1 week ago (FTFY)
I thought it'd be useful to show suggested tags by words you put when you tag a wallpaper, but in no particular order. I believe it'd lessen newly created tags that would have to be merged or aliased.
Some examples, just to illustrate my idea:
- If someone types "gt500", he'll see "Ford Mustang Shelby GT500" in the suggested tags.
- If he types "Holden Monaro", he'll see "Holden VZ Monaro" through other tags in the suggestions.
- If he types "Miku Hatsune" (just so there are not only cars), he'll see "Hatsune Miku" in these.
Again, those are just examples to illustrate.

Yuasu
bends spacetime
  Written 10 months  1 week ago      
Good idea, I support

Eclapa
professional spammer
  Written 10 months  1 week ago      
Thanks. I wonder if I shouldn't rather create that topic in the suggestions section. Meh, it's tag related. Awesome!

Eclapa
professional spammer
  Written 10 months  6 days ago       Last edited by   Eclapa 10 months  6 days ago
*caught* :l

HonorH
advanced writer
  Written 10 months  6 days ago      
Hi there!
This is really an excellent idea! But I dunno if it's easily doable or even if it's not going to be too heavy on the servers.
Let's see what Yotoon has to say.

Eclapa
professional spammer
  Written 10 months  6 days ago       Last edited by   Eclapa 10 months  6 days ago
Salut! Glad to know an admin approves. I don't know if it's heavy and hard to implement, though it doesn't seem like this for me (I know nothing about this anyway). What I know is that it'd be very useful. Hard to not think of it when I see all those car related tags in a mess. Could also work well with anime characters for example.

scissorhands
professional spammer
  Written 10 months  2 days ago      
^ that algorithm would take up way more cpu time than the current sequential one. it would increase the server's load quite a bit.

004
shy visitor
  Written 4 months  2 weeks ago      
good idea but not easy to implement

Yotoon
bends spacetime
  Written 4 months  2 weeks ago      
I would have to add a fulltext search index on the tags table. Search speed and accuracy would be much better but inserting new tags to that table would be a bit slower.

Callvin
aspiring writer
  Written 4 months  2 weeks ago       Last edited by   Callvin 4 months  2 weeks ago
Idea is good, but sometimes number of suggestions is too large to display in a single list (e.g. I've never seen tag at suggestions). This idea will increase number of suggestions => need to modify the drop-down list. For example add scrolling.

HiObbY19
professional spammer
  Written 4 months  2 weeks ago       Last edited by   HiObbY19 4 months  2 weeks ago
What if something like this were implemented only when someone is attempting to create a new tag?

Rather than have a lengthy drop down list appear whenever someone tags an image, have the tag suggestion only kick in when a user is creating a new tag?

The tags currently used on here are "policed" pretty well by the more conscientious users already. It's the constant stream of newly created "bad" or redundant tags that are bothersome.

It would stop someone from creating a Miku Hatsune tag when already exists, without overburdening people who already know the tag is there.

Aneirin
professional spammer
  Written 4 months  2 days ago      
Or could have a suggest button? Keep current functionality, but let people push a button to get a list of suggestions that uses the new code

Eclapa
professional spammer
  Written 2 months  2 weeks ago      
I approve the last two posts. Would that work?

•  Forum home  »  Tagging  »  Better tag suggestions when tagging